Combo Machines. Jointer/Planer. Wide jointer, heavy-duty planer, one small footprint. FineWoodworking.com

of 5

Please download to get full document.

View again

All materials on our website are shared by users. If you have any questions about copyright issues, please report us to resolve them. We are always happy to assist you.
PDF
5 pages
0 downs
3 views
Share
Description
TOOL TEST JOINTER Although their tables are somewhat short, these machines can joint stock up to 12 in. wide, a boon for a small shop. Jointer/Planer ombo Machines Wide jointer, heavy-duty planer, one
Transcript
TOOL TEST JOINTER Although their tables are somewhat short, these machines can joint stock up to 12 in. wide, a boon for a small shop. Jointer/Planer ombo Machines Wide jointer, heavy-duty planer, one small footprint B Y R O L A N D J O H N S O N PLANER All these machines can take deep cuts in hardwoods with no snipe. JOINTER TO PLANER IN 60 SEONDS (MORE OR LESS) It takes only 50 to 80 seconds to change these machines from jointer to planer or vice versa. On most, you first move or detach the jointer fence. Next, pivot the jointer tables up and out of the way (see inset photo). Then pivot the dust hood over the cutterhead and crank the planer bed to the desired height. To change from planer to jointer, lower the planer bed to accommodate the dust hood in its lower position, lower and lock the tables, and replace the fence. The time needed for either changeover directly relates to how much cranking it takes to reset the planer bed. FineWoodworking.com See the jointer-planer changeover in real time. 58 F I N E W O O D W O R K I N G Photos: David Heim Working in a small shop can be a challenge, given the large tools woodworkers rs tend to late. I m always rearranging my tablesaw, bandsaw, aw, accumu- jointer, drill press, workbenches, and dust collecantor to optimize space give myself room to work. ombination jointer/planers commonplace in Europe but still a rarity in the United States maximize available space because they use a single cutterhead for two operations. The jointer bed cally is designed to swing up and out of typi- the way, providing access cess to the planer bed below. An integrated dust hood pivots to accommodate both operations. These machines also present some tions: Do you pay a premium for a combo, ques- compared with separate machines? Do you sacrifice performance, or is a combo chine equal to the sum of its parts? How ma- different is a combo from the machines most of us are accustomed to using? To answer those questions and others, I looked at the four jointer/planer combinations that are moderately priced and readily available. All use a 12-in.-wide cutter head, with jointer beds ranging from 50 in. to 59 in. long. Each manufacturer offers larger, pricier machines, but they are not practical for many hobbyists. One well-known brand, Laguna Tools, is not represented; its redesigned jointer/ planer wasn t available in time for this review. The basic questions, answered All four combo machines delivered excellent results in my tests. Using maple, white oak, and cherry, I face-jointed and edge-jointed long, wide boards without difficulty, and planed b o a r d s with no s n i p e. T h e s e combo machines don t sacrifice performance, and they don t command a steep premium. osts range from $2,500 to $4,400, not much more than a pair of conventional machines. An 8-in. jointer costs List price: $4,400 Power: 230v, 4.8 hp Jointer bed length: 59½ in. Footprint: 64 in. by 36 in. Weight: 650 lb. AUTHOR S MINIMAX USA FS 30 SMART hangeover time: 50 sec. utterhead: Tersa standard. Replacement knives, $45 per set. Euro-style cutterheard guard, $275. MiniMax has the fastest changeover The MiniMax USA has two standout characteristics: It has the same type of swingaway cutterhead guard found on conventional jointers, and it comes with Tersa knives as standard equipment. These disposable knives are extremely easy to change and are held in place with wedges and centrifugal force, so they need no fussy adjustments, as conventional knives do. This machine has other strong points. It takes less than a minute to change modes. That s mainly because the planer bed must be lowered only 3¾ in. (38 cranks) to accommodate the dust hood. The 59½-in. jointer table is one of the longest. It also has the best fence, mounted to a bracket attached to the end of the infeed table. When you switch from jointing to planing, you just lift off the fence in one motion and stow it nearby. (Fences on the others must be loosened, slid to one side, and locked there.) It s also the only one with a stop to prevent it from deflecting sideways under lateral pressure. I found two small drawbacks. One, the MiniMax has two dust-collection ports, so you have to remove and reattach the dust-collector hose at every changeover. Two, the crank that moves the planer bed works counterintuitively clockwise to lower, counterclockwise to lift. It fooled me for a while. Easy off. The MiniMax fence lifts off, easing the changeover from jointing to planing. It s also the easiest to set for angled jointing. Quick change. Tersa knives, standard on the MiniMax, are the easiest to change because they index themselves perfectly. H O I E k i n g.com M A R H / A P R I L AUTHOR S H O I E HAMMER A (East oast) (West oast) List price: $3,582 Power: 230v, 4 hp Jointer bed length: 55 in. Footprint: 61 in. by 27 in. Weight: 660 lb. hangeover time: 1 min. 3 sec. utterhead: Quick-change cartridge. Replacement knives are $31 to $57 per set. Jointer-table extension, $160 Handwheel with digital readout for planer height, $67 Hammer is well-built The Hammer is very nearly the equal of the MiniMax USA. It s a well-engineered, wellmade machine that s a pleasure to use. Its $3,582 list price makes it worth serious consideration. One useful feature on the Hammer is the gravity-actuated stops that prevent the jointer tables from dropping. I also like the height of the jointer tables. At in., they re 2 in. lower than the MiniMax and in. lower than the Rojek. For me, the reduced height made it easier to work around the Euro-style cutterhead guard. artridge knife inserts the only type available for the Hammer are rossing the bridge. The Hammer and the Rojek have a T-shaped guard. It takes a little practice to learn to maneuver over the guard when jointing. nearly as easy to change as Tersa knives. You loosen a set of locking screws, remove the cartridge, reverse or replace the disposable knife, reinstall it in the cutterhead, and tighten the lockscrews with no adjustments needed. On the negative side, the Hammer has a shorter jointer table than two of the others. hangeover takes a little more than a minute and entails 75 turns of the crank to move the planer bed. Pretty quick change. Doubleedged cartridge knife inserts are easy to change and reset without having to make lots of tiny adjustments. as much as $1,700; a heavy-duty planer costs $800 to $1,200. A conventional 12-in. jointer a behemoth next to these combos costs about $4,000 all by itself. How different are they? ombos aren t radically different from conventional jointers or planers, but it takes time to get used to them. You have to change some shop practices to use these machines effectively. It s much more productive to do all the jointing for a piece, then change over to do all the planing. Of course, sometimes you have to joint and plane a single piece, or joint an edge when the machine was last used in planing mode. When you do, you ll encounter an unfamiliar setup step that may seem tedious, especially at first (see Jointer to planer in 60 seconds, p. 58). If you re accustomed to a jointer with a massive cast-iron fence and a swing-away guard over the cutterhead, these combo machines will seem very different. Most have a sliding cutterhead guard, often 60 F I N E W O O D W O R K I N G ROJEK MSP List price: $3,100 Power: 230v, 5 hp Jointer bed length: 59 in. Footprint: 60 in. by 47 in. Weight: 569 lb. hangeover time: 1 min. 20 sec. utterhead: Four-knife cutterblock standard. Replacement knives, $90 (Tersa knives, $99). Optional 3-blade Tersa head, $356 Planer-bed extension, $179 Jointer extension, $190 Rojek offers no-frills performance This is a moderately priced, no-nonsense machine that performs well. The jointer table is a generous 59 in. long. But the Rojek lacks some of the refinements of the MiniMax and the Hammer. For one, its standard cutterhead knives, held in place with traditional jackscrews and locking gibs, take time and patience to install accurately. Rojek supplies a decent dial indicator to help set the knives. You can also outfit the machine with a Tersa cutter head, an option that I recommend. For another, the 315 must be plugged in to change the knives. A switch setting lets you override a motor brake and rotate the cutterhead; it doesn t work if you unplug the machine. I dislike that type of design because of the chance however remote that you could accidentally start the machine. The third big shortcoming is changeover time. I averaged 1 minute, 20 seconds, time spent mainly moving the planer bed the 7½ in. (90-plus cranks) required to accommodate the dust hood. There were other, minor annoyances. The power switches, on the left end of the front panel, are in a slightly inconvenient position for planing because you have to reach around the forwardtilted tables to hit the switch. And the instruction manual is the worst of the lot. The opposite way. The Rojek s jointer tables tilt to the front, unlike the tables on the other machines. When planing, you have to reach around the tilted outfeed table to reach the power switch. No quick change. To loosen the gibs holding the Rojek s knives in place, you need a hammer and a block of scrap. Fine-tuning the knife adjustments takes patience. called a bridge guard, which is designed to let stock pass beneath it when facejointing a board. (Only the MiniMax has a swing-away guard.) Bridge guards are adjustable, so you can move them away from the fence for edge-jointing. I had to get used to passing wide stock beneath the bridge, then reaching over it with my push blocks as I moved the stock to the outfeed side of the cutterhead. But once I d mastered those moves, I appreciated having a guard that covered the cutterhead completely. The fences on these jointer/planers are aluminum extrusions. They hold the angle you ve set resolutely, but most can flex slightly under lateral pressure (the MiniMax fence has a stop to prevent flexing). That doesn t affect the accuracy of the jointing. The bottom line All the jointer/planers are well-made machines that perform their two tasks very k i n g.com M A R H / A P R I L Rojek s low-cost alternative T his is a slightly smaller, simpler version of the Rojek MSP 315. The jointer beds are fixed, not pivoting, a design that makes it harder to set the cutterhead knives properly. ontrols, cutterhead, and fence are essentially the same on both machines. hanging from jointer to planer means raising or lowering the planer bed and moving the dust hood. When planing, the hood cov- ers the cutterhead and a bolt holds it to the fence. When jointing, the hood rests on the planer bed, which you raise to press the hood in place. The changeover is fussy and takes a little over a minute. The dust-collection setup trades simplicity for effectiveness. Plenty of large shavings miss the hood, littering the planer bed and surround- ing nooks and crannies. leaning out the mess quickly becomes tire- some. The other machines have better systems. Because the jointer bed doesn t swing out of the way, the over- hanging outfeed end intrudes when you re feeding stock into the planer. It s an annoyance, but not a hazard. The 310 has a jointer bed that s barely 50 in. long. Extensions, a $190 option, also fit the 315. ROJEK MSP 310M List price: $2,500 Power: 230v, 3.6 hp Jointer bed length: 49½ in. Footprint: 52 in. by 36 in. Weight: 534 lb. hangeover time: 1 min. 9 sec. utterhead: Four-knife cutterblock standard. Replacement knives, $90 (Tersa knives, $99). Optional 3-blade Tersa head, $356 Planer-bed rollers, $179 Jointer extensions, $190 Hangover. The Rojek s jointer table limits your access and view when planing. Dust collection one. For jointing, the dust hood fits underneath the cutterhead and is clamped in place by the planer table. Dust collection two. For planing, the dust hood sits on the jointer table over the cutterhead, held with a bolt in the fence. This low-tech design isn t very effective. well. Some small design details account for the differences among them. The boxes on these pages give the specifics. The Hammer is clearly the best value at about $3,600. It s a well-made machine that s a pleasure to use, and its knives are easy to change. But its fence isn t quite as handy as the one on the MiniMax. The Rojek machines are the least expensive. They perform the basic functions of planing and joining, but are a little more awkward to use. The best overall but only by a nose is the MiniMax, mainly because it has the best overall fence design. It s the easiest to handle when changing from jointer to planer mode, and the easiest to adjust for different angles. A standard Tersa cutterhead is another plus, as is the machine s quick changeover time and long jointer fence. But at $4,400, the MiniMax is also the most expensive jointer/planer tested. Roland Johnson is a contributing editor. 62 F I N E W O O D W O R K I N G
Related Search
We Need Your Support
Thank you for visiting our website and your interest in our free products and services. We are nonprofit website to share and download documents. To the running of this website, we need your help to support us.

Thanks to everyone for your continued support.

No, Thanks